Officially my favorite
piece so far, World War Z hit a level
of depth and character the previous stories fell short of. I had my
reservations coming into the piece, not being a fan of war stories, or stories
with too many POVs, but by the end I was blown away by the novel. The strong voices
really distinguish this piece from all of the others. Each interview reveals a
POV ripe with culture, philosophy, and diversity in every way imaginable. This gives
readers the chance to view the apocalypse from angles all over the globe and
human spectrum, from suburban mom, to international space station astronaut.
For
my favorite part.
I was majorly impressed
by Brooks’ ability to create well developed characters in a handful of pages. So
many of the characters came alive from the get go, but for me, the truly
incredible feat revolves around my favorite character. General Raj Singh was a
larger than life hero, and this fantastic image of him was built without ever
giving him his own POV. The square he had is men form to fight off a zombie
swarm became world famous, and was mentioned by many POV characters. The moment
one of his men had to knock him unconscious to get him to evacuate the lost
battle was viewed from space via satellite. His final moments were brought to
us through a third party POV character who witnessed him run off to detonate
the charges that would avoid a nuclear strike when the remote failed. Through
the thoughts, eyes and ears of other characters, whether right in front of the
General’s face, or literally a world away, Raj Singh was brought to life in a
way that will stick with me even after many of the POV characters fade. This was
one of my favorite parts of the novel, and really shows the power of
characterization.
Now, about the zombies.
The monsters in World War Z were an unstoppable
plague that tore apart the planet. Science and technology were dreadfully
underprepared for a disaster of this magnitude, and so were the social
structures of every country. The book said it best, but to summarize, what made
Zack so effective for me was that the monster’s destructive powers weren’t an
inherent thing the creature possessed, but rather the exact way they combined
with the faults of humanity. Another race, a better race, one more
sophisticated, ethical, and united would never have succumbed to Zack the way
humans did. The zombie is humanity turned against itself, both in the literal sense
(zombies were people) and in the metaphorical sense (much of the devastation in
World War Z came from people not
getting along and doing things like launching nukes at each other.) I appreciate
this poetic symmetry.
Another thing that
really hit the spot with this work, was that it did the exact opposite of what
many previous works earned my nerd rage for. World War Z acknowledged the scientific faults in it, and it made
it more believable. Characters bring up both the fact that Zach somehow doesn’t
rot in sea water, and the miraculous survival of the zombie’s brain tissue even
after being frozen and thawed. This made
my nerd heart feel so warm. Thank you. Thank you for acknowledging the fact
that science exists and should work, but doesn’t and no one knows why. That’s all
I ever wanted.
The only thing I really
found at fault with this piece is the lack of clarity in naming the different
POV characters. The interviews are titled by location, and in many cases, the
narrator’s opening narration leaves out the name of who he is interviewing. Though
the voices were so strong I could usually tell when a repeat POV came up, it
would have been nice to have the names readily available at the beginning of
the POVs. Especially when you have to write a blog post. I don’t know the name
of the Air force woman with the imaginary sky watcher “Mets” off the top of my
head. And there are wonderful characters I can only refer to as Astronaut Man, Dog
Man, and Resorted to Cannibalism Girl without pouring through the pages. They sound
like bad superheroes.
But overall, World War Z has become a personal favorite.
Astronaut Man, Dog Man, and Cannibalism Girl would be a very, very dark hero team indeed.
ReplyDeleteNice analysis of the science disparity/illogic. I think that showed a very keen attention to detail on Brooks' part.
Brooks did a great job crafting POVs that were unique and individual. While sometimes they may have sounded similar, each had their own personality. With all the shifts in situation, location, and time, the shift in POV didn't distract as much as I thought it would.
ReplyDeleteAnd they sound more like super villains to me.
"Another race, a better race, one more sophisticated, ethical, and united would never have succumbed to Zack the way humans did."
ReplyDeleteGood summation. My greatest fear in a Zombie Apocalypse wouldn't be the Zombies. It would be my fellow humans. We would be so busy arguing over who's to blame and shooting each other that the Zombies would starve.
Astronaut Man, Dog Man, and Resorted to Cannibalism Girl sound like a pretty good Superhero Team to me. (In oral histories, individual names often take a backseat to the experience.)
I didn't realize that it was a trait of oral histories, but I also wish that the names of the interviewees had been more apparent. I was also using morbid superhero names to keep the characters straight.
ReplyDeleteI love it when little scientific details like that are brought up. (Of course, I also liked the faulty science of I Am Legend, so make of that what you will. xD) It takes it a step beyond, "Because they're zombies" or "Because this is fiction" by having the characters acknowledge it.
ReplyDeleteI like your point about the zombies exploiting humanity's weaknesses almost perfectly. They really work as a backdrop to show all the petty and awful things people are capable of. The phalanx chapter is probably my least favorite, just because it's so true. That's exactly what some people would do if this really happened.
ReplyDeleteSCIENCE!!
ReplyDeleteThe science behind WWZ is one of the many things that to me not only made the book seem more realistic but also made it seem like less of a zombie book and more like a bazillion other books. As far as that goes you could put this zombie plague up there with the best deadly-virus-threatens-to-wipe-out-humanity story.
Brooks really does handle characterization well. It was so easy to just zone out and believe the stories were being told by actual people. And, since there are so many stories, the book feels more like a collection of short stories rather than a novel, which I prefer to read since it is easier to digest in small chunks.
ReplyDelete